Name: Paige Noel Coffey
Age: 27 years old
Last Seen: May 7, 2019
Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Status: Found deceased on April 17, 2026
Case Information
27 year old Paige Coffey was last seen in Cleveland, Ohio on May 7, 2019. She was last seen with her boyfriend at the Steelyard Commons shopping center.
Background
Paige worked at the Torrid store in Macedonia, Ohio at the time of her disappearance. She sometimes lived with her grandmother in Bratenahl, Ohio.
Disappearance
On May 7, 2019, Paige Coffey was last seen with her boyfriend leaving the Home Depot store in the Steelyard Commons shopping center in Cleveland, Ohio. Paige never returned home, and hasn’t been heard from since.
Her mother reported her missing to the Bratenahl Police Department on May 17, 2019.
Paige has ties to Copley, Macedonia, Oakwood Village, and South Euclid. Her loved ones say it’s uncharacteristic of her to leave without warning.
Coffey’s family members fear she may be in danger due to a change in mental status, according to police.
Paige Coffey Found Deceased
On April 17, 2026, Paige’s remains were found inside a garbage bag at an abandoned home in the 3800 block of East 142nd Street in Cleveland. The discovery way made after police received a report of remains being found during a clean up of the property.
The investigation into the cause and manner of death remains ongoing.
Appearance
Black female with brown hair and brown eyes. Paige stands 5’8 tall and weighs 230-260 pounds.
She has a sleeve type tattoo of piano keys on one of her arms. Paige had collar length brown hair at the time of her disappearance, and would often wear wigs and change her hairstyle.
Investigating Agency
If you have any information regarding Paige Coffey’s please contact the Bratenahl Police Department at (216) 681-1234, or Crime Stoppers at (216) 252-7463. Tips can also be submitted online.
Agency case number 1900335.
There is a $15,000 reward for information leading to Paige’s location.
Resources & Further Information
Paige Noel Coffey – NamUs
Paige Noel Natasia Coffey – The Charley Project
Family Raises Reward to $15,000 For Missing Woman, Asking For Tips on National Missing Persons Day – 19News
Bratenahl Woman Still Missing Since May, Family Increases Reward Money – 19News
There is updated information in this case that suggests that she was met with foul play, there is a person of interest. He is currently in prison for another offense. There is a recent interview with her mother and News Nation where this is discussed. This is worth mentioning since her mental health was also listed as a possible reason for her disapearance. I would lean more towards the other reason though…